Sunlit finished dining nook with oak furniture, neutral walls and a view of a quiet late-autumn backyard.

How Rigby's New Homes Compare Once You Count Only Finished Space

Two new homes in Hailey Creek, east of Rigby, are about $30,000 apart. 128 Orless St, a Willow plan, is listed at $588,900 for 2,961 square feet, with five bedrooms and two and a half baths. 959 Moor Dr, a Madison plan, is listed at $558,900 for 3,453 square feet, with three bedrooms and two baths. The less expensive house is listed as the larger one and has fewer bedrooms, because a good share of its square footage is an unfinished basement.

The same thing shows up across Rigby's new-construction listings this fall. The square footage a builder lists and the space you can live in on move-in day are often two different numbers. Once you account for that, the homes rank differently on value.

Hailey Creek's list, read by finished space

Hailey Creek, which Kartchner Homes is building near Hwy 48 and Hailey Creek Ave, has the largest builder inventory around Rigby right now. In mid-November 2026, Kartchner's list for the community ran from townhomes on Sharra Ave to four-car-garage detached plans on Orless St, Ashlyn Way and Moor Dr, all with Rigby addresses.

The townhomes have the lowest prices. On Sharra Ave, Stonehaven townhomes are listed at $342,900 for 1,619 square feet, and the 1,762-square-foot units at 1024 Sharra Ave are $352,900. All have three bedrooms, two and a half baths and a two-car garage. The smallest detached home on the list is 876 Jaylee Dr, a four-bedroom Princeton at $417,900 with 1,897 square feet on a 0.14-acre lot. 1169 Sharra Ave, a 2,631-square-foot Ashland at $525,900, sits on a quarter acre. Kartchner says the community's park and sports courts are for townhome residents.

Kartchner lists one square-footage figure per home. On the plans named "With Unfinished Basement," that figure includes the basement. Here is price per listed square foot for a few of those homes, using the builder's prices as of mid-November 2026:

Home Builder's listed price Listed sq ft Price per listed sq ft
1062 Sharra Ave #1, Stonehaven townhome, 3 bed $342,900 1,619 about $212
876 Jaylee Dr, Princeton, 4 bed $417,900 1,897 about $220
128 Orless St, Willow, 5 bed $588,900 2,961 about $199
959 Moor Dr, Madison with unfinished basement, 3 bed $558,900 3,453 about $162
981 Ashlyn Way, Richmond with unfinished basement, 4 bed $508,900 3,543 about $144

By this measure, the basement plans look like the best value. That holds for a buyer who plans to finish the basement over time, because the space is already under the roof they are paying for. For a buyer who needs every bedroom at closing, the Willow at 128 Orless St has more usable space than 959 Moor Dr, even though it is listed as smaller. The two numbers answer different questions, and a portal median per square foot answers neither.

Fieldstone Meadows lists both numbers

Rockwell Homes, which builds in Fieldstone Meadows, lists total and finished square footage separately. 540 Shamrock, a quick-move-in Dalton, is listed at $395,000 with three bedrooms, two baths, 2,830 total square feet and 1,422 finished. On total space, that comes to about $140 a foot. On finished space, it is about $278. Both numbers describe the same house. The 1,408 unfinished square feet are worth a lot to a buyer who plans to finish them and much less to one who doesn't.

Fieldstone Meadows also has smaller lots than many buyers expect in Rigby. The Jefferson Star reported that Rockwell's plan used 75-by-125-foot lots for 17 more single-family homes, which the builder presented as a way to keep homes affordable. Lots that size are part of how a detached new home here can list under $400,000.

On 3800 East, the price includes an acre

Saddle Hill, at 375 N 3800 E, is a different purchase. Hamlet Homes describes it as a mixed-builder neighborhood of one-acre lots with private well and septic, fiber internet, walking paths and a community park with basketball and pickleball. Hamlet's two quick-move-in homes there are 3771 East 369 North at $669,990, with five bedrooms, four and a half baths and 4,129 square feet, and 3761 East 369 North at $679,990, with six bedrooms, four baths, 4,015 square feet and a three-car garage. Hamlet's base prices for its two Saddle Hill floor plans are $569,990 for The Harrison and $584,990 for The William.

Copper Creek Homes builds nearby in what it calls the Saddle Hills Subdivision. Its completed spec home at 3765 E 356 N is listed at $549,900 with three bedrooms, two baths and 3,280 total square feet. A second spec at 3763 E 356 N is on a one-acre lot, with price on request.

By listed square footage, the Hamlet homes come to about $162 to $169 a foot and the Copper Creek spec to about $168. That is close to Hailey Creek's basement plans, and these homes come with an acre of land. These builders' Rigby listings run from quarter-acre and smaller homesites in Hailey Creek and Fieldstone Meadows to acre homesites along 3800 East, so a buyer weighing yard size is choosing between those two ends.

More ground on that same road is in play. A request to rezone about 143 acres at the southeast corner of N 3800 E and E 500 N was on the Jefferson County Planning and Zoning Commission's Nov. 18, 2026 agenda, and the county staff report is posted on the county's site.

Where the builder incentives are

The builders' current offers are on homes that are already built or under construction. Much of the Hailey Creek inventory is due to finish this winter. Kartchner lists 1040 Sharra Ave #1 and #4 for 01/01/2027, 876 Jaylee Dr for 02/01/2027, and 1024 Sharra Ave #2 and #3 for 03/01/2027. Several homes on the list are tagged "Save On This Home," and the site advertises a 5.99% rate lock.

Hamlet's "Up to $25K Your Way" offer is also tied to inventory homes. It applies only to select quick-move-in homes, can go toward a rate buydown, closing costs or a price reduction, isn't guaranteed at the full amount, and can't be combined with lender incentive promotions. It does not apply to presale or build-to-order homes. For a buyer whose timeline fits a home finishing in the next few months, those are the homes the builders are offering money on. These figures are general information and not financial advice, so confirm the terms of any rate or credit with your lender and the builder.

Quick answers

Are Rigby townhomes the cheapest way into new construction? By sticker price, yes. Hailey Creek's Stonehaven units start at $342,900 as listed in mid-November 2026. At about $212 per listed square foot, they cost more per foot than the larger and basement plans in the table and a little less than the Princeton at 876 Jaylee Dr. You can browse current Rigby townhomes alongside single-family homes.

What utilities do Saddle Hill homes have? Hamlet lists private well and septic, along with fiber internet. Our post on how Rigby and Idaho Falls compare covers why water belongs on any Rigby acreage checklist.

Can I buy just a lot and build? Copper Creek has build-on-your-lot options in the Saddle Hills Subdivision, including a listed premium lot. Current options are on our Rigby land page.

If you're comparing a Sharra Ave townhome, a basement plan on Moor Dr and an acre on 3800 East, I'll put them side by side with you. We'll compare finished square feet, lot size and which incentive applies to each home, so every number means the same thing. Schedule your free consultation with Adam Walz and bring the addresses you're considering.

Buy & Sell With Confidence

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram